Rather, shame on you! Before archaeologists discovered the ruins of Nineveh in modern-day Iraq, people were talking just like you about “fictional” places.
There are plenty of people trying to connect the mythical Camelot with modern English places. The far end of the Dead Sea would be a terrific location for an obscenely wealthy and self-centred kingdom, because they would be able to trade salt to passing caravans. That there IS evidence for such a city does not mean that this is either Sodom or Gomorrah, but if one is spinning a tale of corrupt morality and the consequences thereof, the big ruined city over yonder makes a tempting location for one’s narrative.
As to the reason for abandoning the city, lack of potable water is a good bet, and the modern problem of sinkhole collapse would be another. Caravan routes changed for a variety of reasons, as the Nabateans discovered: they eventually abandoned Petra despite the fact that the water-harvesting technology still works! No caravans = no business = no reason to stay.
5 Comments
Richard Parks
This guy is trying to fit a fictional place “sodom” into the real word. Shame on him.
Richard Parks
World
Ephraim
Rather, shame on you! Before archaeologists discovered the ruins of Nineveh in modern-day Iraq, people were talking just like you about “fictional” places.
Jason Unwin
“Sodom”, a “proper noun”. A place. 🙂
Axel Bushing
There are plenty of people trying to connect the mythical Camelot with modern English places. The far end of the Dead Sea would be a terrific location for an obscenely wealthy and self-centred kingdom, because they would be able to trade salt to passing caravans. That there IS evidence for such a city does not mean that this is either Sodom or Gomorrah, but if one is spinning a tale of corrupt morality and the consequences thereof, the big ruined city over yonder makes a tempting location for one’s narrative.
As to the reason for abandoning the city, lack of potable water is a good bet, and the modern problem of sinkhole collapse would be another. Caravan routes changed for a variety of reasons, as the Nabateans discovered: they eventually abandoned Petra despite the fact that the water-harvesting technology still works! No caravans = no business = no reason to stay.